FYI: This website contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
By Amy DeVries
Short answer: These carob chip cookies are thick, chewy, and gluten free. They're made with almond flour, coconut flour, coconut oil, and carob chips instead of chocolate, so they're dairy free, soy free, and caffeine-free as written. They take a little more effort than a boxed mix, which is why they're our special-treat cookie, not an everyday one.

I can't eat chocolate. After being away from it for a long time, I had some and got my first and only migraine. That was the end of chocolate for me.
Carob filled the gap better than I expected. To me it tastes very similar to chocolate, just milder and naturally sweet, with none of the bitterness. It feels indulgent, and it's become my special treat.
Chocolate chip cookies were always my favorite, mostly because of the dough: rich and not too sweet. These get there without butter. Solid coconut oil and almond butter do that job, and homegrown eggs hold it together.
One warning: I like my cookies thick and chewy, and that's what this recipe makes.
The big chunks in these are homemade carob chips. Most of the time I use store-bought chips.These days we buy Missy J's organic unsweetened carob chips. I rarely make my own, except when I want big chunks like the ones in these photos.
If you're new to carob, my Carob Chips page covers what they are, how carob compares with chocolate, and whether to buy or make them, plus my homemade chip recipe.
Can you eat chocolate? Swap in chocolate chips. Just check the label if you're baking around food allergies.
A few small choices give this cookie its texture:
By Amy DeVries
Thick, chewy, gluten free cookies made with almond flour, coconut flour, coconut oil, and carob chips instead of chocolate, mixed by hand with a pastry cutter.
Prep time:
Cook time:
Yield: 16 cookies
Tips for carob chip cookies
I let a few people who can eat anything try these. They noticed a slightly nutty taste and asked if there was peanut butter in them. There isn't; they were tasting the almond butter.
Everyone agreed the cookies are very rich and filling. One is usually plenty.
I liked these photos so much that I used them for an acrylic painting of a cookie. The painting decorates our house now.
My cookie painting, inspired by this batch.The hardest part of a treat bake like this isn't the baking. It's the half-used bags of almond flour and coconut flour that drift to the back of the pantry afterward.
We keep open bags like those on our use-first shelf, so they get used in the next batch instead of forgotten. I explain how we set that up on my Eat Me First Bin page.
If you'd like one small first step toward wasting less, my free guide, Which Urban Homestead System Should You Start First?, helps you pick a starting point that fits your space and energy.
This is what I use for these cookies. You don't need a stand mixer; a pastry cutter does the creaming.
If you want to make your own carob chunks, the molds and powder I use are on my Carob Chips page.
Ready to plan more than one small system? My $12 Small-Space Self-Sufficiency Starter Map helps you choose your first three.
Can I use chocolate chips instead of carob chips?
Yes. Use 1/2 to 1 cup of chocolate chips, and check the label if you're baking around food allergies.
Do carob chip cookies taste like chocolate chip cookies?
To me, they're very close. Carob is milder and naturally sweet, without chocolate's bitterness. Tasters also noticed a slightly nutty flavor from the almond butter.
Can I make these with butter?
I haven't tried it. This recipe is written for solid coconut oil, which keeps it dairy free.
Are these cookies egg free?
No, they use one egg. I haven't tested an egg substitute in this recipe.
Are carob chip cookies caffeine-free?
Carob is caffeine-free, so these are too when you make them with carob chips. Chocolate chips would add caffeine.
Why does the recipe use both almond flour and coconut flour?
Almond flour makes up most of the dough. The small amount of coconut flour helps it hold together so the cookies bake up thick.